Justice Bhatia's Recusal: A Judicial Jolt

Justice Pankaj Bhatia of the Allahabad High Court recused himself from hearing bail pleas after a Supreme Court ruling criticized his earlier decision. The apex court's remarks had a demoralizing effect on the judge, compelling him to request the withdrawal of bail case assignments from him.


Devdiscourse News Desk | Lucknow | Updated: 14-02-2026 00:09 IST | Created: 14-02-2026 00:09 IST
Justice Bhatia's Recusal: A Judicial Jolt
  • Country:
  • India

Justice Pankaj Bhatia of the Allahabad High Court's Lucknow bench has stepped back from presiding over bail applications. The decision follows sharp criticism from the Supreme Court over a previous bail order made by Justice Bhatia.

The Supreme Court's observations had a considerable impact, with Bhatia highlighting a 'huge demoralising and chilling effect' that has affected his ability to handle such cases impartially. The contentious bail order involved a man accused in a dowry death case, previously granted bail by Justice Bhatia.

The Supreme Court's stern remarks prompted Justice Bhatia to request the chief justice to reassign bail matters to other judges, marking a significant development in judicial proceedings within the high court. The apex court's scrutiny reflects ongoing concerns over the handling of serious criminal cases.

Give Feedback